An Optimal Criminal Policy toward Deepfakes: A Maximalist or Minimalist Response?

Authors

Keywords:

 Deepfake, criminal policy, artificial intelligence, maximum response, minimum response, cybercrime, non, criminal prevention

Abstract

With the emergence and rapid expansion of deepfake technology and the use of artificial intelligence to generate realistic fabricated content, societal psychological security, privacy, and the integrity of democratic institutions have been exposed to novel threats. By enabling identity impersonation and the manipulation of reality, this technology has created unprecedented challenges for criminal justice systems. This study aims to analyze and explain the optimal criminal policy for addressing this phenomenon and to determine whether a “maximalist response”—involving the use of severe punitive and coercive measures—or a “minimalist response”—relying on civil remedies, platform self-regulation, and non-criminal preventive mechanisms—can adequately respond to the requirements of this emerging threat. Using a descriptive-analytical method and drawing on library-based and documentary research, the study comparatively examines legislative and judicial approaches adopted in various legal systems and analyzes criminal policies concerning artificial intelligence–enabled cybercrime. The findings indicate that, owing to the technology-driven nature of deepfakes, their rapid dissemination, and the fluid boundary between “creativity” and “crime,” the adoption of a maximalist penal policy, or absolute punitivism, may result in violations of civil liberties and prove ineffective in preventing harm. Conversely, a minimalist policy lacks sufficient deterrent capacity when deepfakes pose threats to national security or cause large-scale reputational harm. The findings therefore demonstrate the need to adopt a “participatory and stratified criminal policy.” An optimal criminal policy toward deepfakes should involve neither an exclusively maximalist response nor the abandonment of responsibility under a minimalist approach. Instead, a “hybrid criminal policy model” is proposed. Under this model, precise and proportionate criminal sanctions should be applied to high-risk abuses, such as large-scale fraud and systematic reputational or institutional destruction, whereas the broad range of low-risk content should primarily be addressed through non-criminal policies, enhanced accountability of technology platforms, improved media literacy among citizens, and the development of digital authentication and content-provenance tools.

References

Albahar, M., & Almalki, J. (2019). Deepfakes: Threats and countermeasures systematic review. Computer Science, Political Science, Law, 97(22), 1817-1852.

Alian, I., & Faker Meybodi, M. (2018). Proportionality of crime and punishment based on the verses of qisas. Tafsir Studies, 9(36), 29-46.

Arabiyan, A., & Akhtari, S. (2024). A comparative study of maximum criminalization in Iran and the United States. Interdisciplinary Studies of Jurisprudence, 4(16), 143-164.

Bakhshizadeh, T., Bashiriyeh, T., & Gholami, H. (2023). The principle of the minimum nature of criminal law in Iranian criminal law: Challenges and solutions. Teachings of Criminal Jurisprudence and Law(7), 65-84.

Cejudo, R. (2023). Ethical problems of the use of deepfakes in the arts and culture. In Ethics of Artificial Intelligence. Springer Nature Switzerland.

Gamage, D. (2022). Are deepfakes concerning? Analyzing conversations of deepfakes on Reddit and exploring societal implications. CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems,

Ghannad, F., & Akbari, M. (2017). Securitization of criminal policy. Criminal Law Research Quarterly, 5(18), 39-67.

Ghodrati, N., Mirkhalili, S. M., & Haji Dehabadi, M. A. (2023). Legal consequences of pervasive criminalization in Iran's judicial system. Islamic Law, 20(78), 7-34.

Kulger, M. B., & Pace, C. (2021). Deepfake privacy: Attitudes and regulation. Northwestern University Law Review, 116(3), 611-680.

Lussier, N. (2022). Nonconsensual deepfakes: Detecting and regulating this rising threat to privacy. Idaho Law Review, 58(2), 353-383.

Majidi, S. M. (2009). Manifestations of security-oriented criminal law in France. Private Law Studies, 39(2), 327-344.

Majidi, S. M., & Tajabadi, F. (2019). Security-oriented criminalization techniques in Iranian criminal law. Studies in Islamic Jurisprudence and Law(21), 289-316.

Maras, M. A., & Alexandrou. (2018). Determining authenticity of video evidence in the age of artificial intelligence and in the wake of deepfake videos. International Journal of Evidence and Proof, 23(2), 255-262.

Mohammadnejad, H., & Tajik, R. (2019). Causes of maximum criminalization and the requirements for its structural transformation in Iran. Private Law Research(38), 131-152.

Nguyen, D. S. W., & Ademiluyi, D. T. (2023). Deepfake video detection employing human facial features. Journal of Computer and Communications, 11(12), 1-13.

Rahmdel, M. (2023). Proportionality of Crime and Punishment. SAMT.

Sabzevarinejad, H. (2017). The position of the principle of proportionality between crime and punishment in Iranian and English criminal law. Judicial Law Perspectives Quarterly, 22(77), 133-164.

Sheikh, S., Ghiyasi, J. a.-D., & Salehi, M. K. (2022). A reflection on the pathology of substantive legislative criminal policy concerning currency crimes against security. Iranian Political Sociology, 5(10), 193-205.

Tajabadi, F., & Meshkani, A. H. (2022). Security-oriented criminal policy techniques (zero tolerance): Challenges of public law and human rights. National Conference on Professor Katouzian and Public Law Thought, Bushehr.

Vizoso, Á., Vaz-Álvarez, M., & García, X. L. (2021). Fighting deepfakes: Media and internet giants' converging and diverging strategies against hi-tech misinformation. Media and Communication, 9(1), 291-300.

Yang Chik, A., & Samsudin, S. A. B. (2023). Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Law and Digitalization 2023 (ICLD 2023).

Yazdian Jafari, J. (2008). The principle of proportionality between crime and punishment: Its why and how. Nameh-ye Mofid, 14(67), 139-156.

Zakerinia, H., & Gholampour, Z. (2024). Reasonable and customary algorithms and strengthening the theory of imputability of civil liability for artificial intelligence. Journal of Contract Law and Emerging Technologies, 5(1), 155-168.

Zhang, W., Zhao, C., & Li, Y. (2020). A novel counterfeit feature extraction technique for exposing face-swap images based on deep learning and error level analysis. Entropy, 22(2), 249-268.

Downloads

Publication Timeline

Published
Submitted
Revised
Accepted

Issue

Section

مقالات

How to Cite

Sajedinia, H. . ., Amirpour, H. . ., Jamshidirad, M. . ., & Abdolahpour, A. . (1405). An Optimal Criminal Policy toward Deepfakes: A Maximalist or Minimalist Response?. Comparative Studies in Jurisprudence, Law, and Politics, 1-18. https://csjlp.org/index.php/csjlp/article/view/767