Mitigation of Criminal Responsibility in Light of Recent Neuroscientific Findings

Authors

Keywords:

criminal responsibility, neuroscience, neurolaw, volition, awareness, impulse control, individualization of punishment, Islamic criminal jurisprudence

Abstract

Remarkable advances in neuroscience over recent decades have prompted reconsideration of one of the fundamental premises of criminal law: the attribution of responsibility on the basis of volition, awareness, and freedom of choice. Traditional criminal law is generally founded on the assumption that an ordinary person is capable of understanding the nature of their conduct, foreseeing its consequences, and controlling their actions. Recent neuroscientific findings, however, indicate that certain forms of criminal behavior—particularly impulsive, violent, and emotionally driven acts—may be associated with impaired executive brain functions, deficient impulse control, damage to the prefrontal cortex, and deficits in judgment and emotional regulation. The necessity of this study arises from the inadequacy of the traditional dichotomy between “full responsibility” and “absence of responsibility” in addressing individuals who neither suffer from a complete loss of reason nor possess ordinary volitional and cognitive capacities. Moreover, in Islamic jurisprudence and Iranian criminal law, criminal responsibility is founded on the elements of reason, intent, free will, awareness, and imputability. Accordingly, examining the effects of biological and neurological factors on these elements is not only necessary but also consistent with the justice-oriented foundations of this legal system. This study aimed to explain the extent to which recent neuroscientific findings may contribute to the mitigation of criminal responsibility and to assess the compatibility of such an approach with the jurisprudential and legal foundations of Iran. Using a descriptive-analytical method and an interdisciplinary approach, the study examined jurisprudential and legal sources alongside reliable neuroscientific evidence to analyze the capacity of the criminal justice system to accommodate emerging models of responsibility. The findings indicate that the acceptance of reliable neuroscientific evidence does not necessarily lead to biological determinism or the denial of human agency; rather, it may provide a basis for adopting a realistic model referred to as the “spectrum model of responsibility.” Under this model, a distinction is drawn among full responsibility, diminished responsibility, and the absence of responsibility, while the criminal justice response is calibrated according to the severity of impairments in volition, awareness, and behavioral control. Moving toward a more precise individualization of criminal responsibility and punishment, supported by multidisciplinary expert assessments, may constitute an effective step toward achieving criminal justice in light of recent neuroscientific findings.

References

Alimardani, A., Rayejian Asli, M., Vahedi, M., & Khani, M. H. (2017). The role of mental disorders leading to criminal behavior in degrees of criminal responsibility. Journal of the Iranian Medical Council, 35(1).

Azadi, B. (2025a). Explaining the concept and criterion of criminal responsibility and neurological disorders in Iranian criminal law. Eleventh International Conference on Jurisprudence, Law, Advocacy, and Social Sciences in the Horizon of Iran 2025, Mashhad.

Azadi, B. (2025b). Neurological disorders and their role in criminal responsibility. Eleventh International Conference on Jurisprudence, Law, Advocacy, and Social Sciences in the Horizon of Iran 2025, Mashhad.

Bazvand, V., & Nourmohammadi, H. (2021). Criminal responsibility in its abstract concept and the scope of its application to the conduct of legal persons: From theoretical analysis to judicial response. Legal Research, 20(47).

Doroushi, G., Masri, M., Taheri, S. K., & Norouzi, S. (2016). Examining instances of lack of discernment and will from the perspective of forensic medicine and criminal law. Iranian Journal of Forensic Medicine, 22(2).

Eghbali, N. (2020). The Effects of Emotion on Criminal Responsibility. Ostad-e Parsian.

Feyz, A. (2010). Comparison and Adaptation in Islamic General Criminal Law. Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance.

Gholami, A., & Meybodi, H. (2013). The objectives of implementing hudud punishments in the words of jurists and the mechanism for resolving their conflict. Fiqh-e Ahl al-Bayt, 19(76).

Haji Dehabadi, A. (2014). Rules of Criminal Jurisprudence. Research Institute of Hawzah and University.

Hatami, M., Ahmari, H., Kazemi Golvardi, M. R., & Shayeganfar, M. (2025). Examining the relationship between the no-harm rule and criminal responsibility with a view to Imam Khomeini's jurisprudential opinions. Comparative Research in Jurisprudence, Law, and Politics, 7(3).

Imani, M. (2020). A comparative study of the indicators of the mental element of crime in the legal systems of Iran and England University of Tabriz].

Javanbakht, M., & Mohammadi, S. (2016). Conflict between the principle of proportionality of crime and punishment and the objectives of punishments: With a view to Imamiyyah jurisprudence and criminal law. Defense Lawyer Journal, 1(15).

Karaki, A. i. a.-H. (1987). Jami' al-Maqasid. Al al-Bayt.

Khorasani, M. K. (1999). Kifayat al-Usul. Islamic Publishing Institute.

Najafi, M. H. (1997). Jawahir al-Kalam. Dar Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi.

Nourbaha, R. (2014). A Look at the Islamic Penal Code. Mizan Publications.

Petfat, A., Abbasi, M., & Zali, A. (2021). Application of neuroscientific evidence in modern criminal law with emphasis on neuro-litigation in Canada and the United Kingdom. Medical Law Research Journal, 15(56).

Peyvandi, Z., & Allahverdiha, M. M. (2022). Criminal sociology and criminal behavior. Second National Conference on Law, Jurisprudence, and Culture, Shiraz.

Qomashi, S., & Mottaghi Ardakani, O. (2020). The objectives of punishment in light of the behaviorist paradigm. Criminal Law Research Quarterly, 8(30).

Rabbani, M. (2024). The principle of the rule of law in criminal proceedings Islamic Azad University, Shiraz].

Salari, A., & Qomashi, S. (2024). Diminished criminal responsibility arising from relative mental disorders in Iranian criminal law. Criminal Law and Criminology Research, 12(24).

Shayegh, M., & Shayegh, M. R. (2018). Examination of the rule of discretionary punishment according to what the ruler deems appropriate, with a case study of discretionary imprisonment. Jurisprudence and Principles, 3(50).

Zarei Kamalieh, M. (2020). Analysis and examination of the philosophy of punishment and its foundations in jurisprudence and law. Qanun Yar, 4(14).

Downloads

Publication Timeline

Published
Submitted
Revised
Accepted

Issue

Section

مقالات

How to Cite

Shorey, F. . (1406). Mitigation of Criminal Responsibility in Light of Recent Neuroscientific Findings. Comparative Studies in Jurisprudence, Law, and Politics, 1-23. https://csjlp.org/index.php/csjlp/article/view/773