An Examination of Legal Challenges and Strategies for Enhancing Alternatives to Imprisonment in Iranian and Egyptian Law

Authors

Keywords:

Alternative punishments to imprisonment, legal challenges, comparative criminal policy, Iran, Egypt, Criminal Procedure Code 2025, judicial oversight

Abstract

Contemporary criminal policies worldwide are grappling with the crisis of prison overcrowding and the ineffectiveness of incarceration in the rehabilitation of offenders. In response to this challenge, the legal systems of Iran and Egypt have incorporated alternatives to imprisonment into their legislative frameworks as lenient and rehabilitative measures through the enactment of laws such as the 2013 Islamic Penal Code of Iran and Egypt’s New Criminal Procedure Law No. 174 of 2025. Nevertheless, the substantial gap between law on the books and practical implementation has confronted this institution with numerous legal, structural, and cultural challenges. Using a descriptive–analytical–comparative method and drawing on library-based sources, the present study examines these challenges in the Iranian and Egyptian legal systems and proposes strategies for enhancing their effectiveness. The findings indicate that, despite its desirable flexibility and social-work-oriented approach, the Iranian legal system suffers from legal ambiguities in defining violations, inadequate supervisory infrastructure, and cultural resistance among judges. In contrast, although the Egyptian legal system has moved toward greater quantitative transparency and the assignment of an economic value to community service, it suffers from an excessive concentration of authority in the Public Prosecution, the predominance of a security-oriented approach over a rehabilitative approach, and the suppression of independent civil society organizations. By proposing measures such as clarifying the definition of violations, establishing a specialized judicial supervision institution, determining a monetary conversion rate for community service, and expanding the participation of non-governmental organizations, the article emphasizes the need to integrate qualitative and quantitative approaches in both legal systems in order to achieve a balance between implementation effectiveness and the humanitarian objectives of punishment.

References

Abd al-Muttalib, I. (2010). Modern Criminal Encyclopedia in Explaining the Penal Code According to the Latest Amendments Issued by Law No. 95 of 2003. Dar al-Kitab al-Arabi.

Al-Ajras, M. (2025). Alternatives to Custodial Sentences in Egyptian Legislation. Egyptian Criminal Journal, 42(3), 125-156.

Al-Allama al-Hilli, H. i. Y. (1992). Qawa'id al-Ahkam fi Ma'rifat al-Halal wa al-Haram. Islamic Publishing Office of the Society of Seminary Teachers.

Al-Fawzan, M. i. B. (2014). Rules of Imprisonment, Detention, and Arrest: A Comparative Study. Dar al-Marwa.

Al-Jaziri, A. a.-R. (1985). Islamic Jurisprudence According to the Four Schools (Vol. 5). Dar Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi.

Al-Sarhan, Y. F. (2025). The Role of the Public Prosecution in Protecting Human Rights During the Stages of Criminal Proceedings. Katib.

Ghasemi, M., Delfani, R., & Nosrati, Y. (2020). Alternatives to imprisonment in the judicial practice of the Islamic Republic of Iran and their implementation strategies. Iranian Political Sociology(9), 852-865.

Gholami, H., & Khaksar, D. (2019). Factors affecting the imposition of alternatives to imprisonment. Criminal Law Research, 8(26), 9-40.

Habibi, A., Matin Rasekh, M., & Farahbakhsh, M. (2019). Challenges and solutions of a gender-oriented approach to alternatives to imprisonment in Iran's criminal justice system. Iranian Political Sociology, 2(7), 388-406.

Haghdadi, M., Mousavi, S. S., Salehi, A., & Kanjouri, M. (2024). Examining criminal court decisions on the application of alternatives to imprisonment in the Iranian legal system. Ghanoonyar, 8(33), 120-137.

Haji-Tabar Firouzjaei, H. (2014). Alternatives to Imprisonment in Iranian Criminal Law. Ferdowsi Publications.

Haji-Tabar Firouzjaei, H., Firouzian Haji, H., & Kalantari, K. (2021). Challenges arising from ambiguity in the Islamic Penal Code at the stage of implementing alternatives to imprisonment. Judicial Legal Perspectives(96), 43-68.

Harja, M. M. (2021). Encyclopedia of Commentary on the Criminal Procedure Law: Part Two. Dar al-Mahmoud for Publishing and Distribution.

Jaderi, H. (2016). Alternatives to Imprisonment in the Islamic Penal Code: With Emphasis on Fixed and Daily Fine Penalties. Hezar Rang.

Jafari, M. (2020). Examining the importance and barriers to implementing alternatives to imprisonment in Iran. Horizons of Humanities(38), 65-79.

Janipour, K., Ahmadi, A., & Janipour, A. (2021). Alternatives to imprisonment in Iranian and international law: Challenges and solutions. Political Strategy(19), 221-241.

Khaksar, D. (2023). Iran's Criminal Policy Regarding Alternatives to Imprisonment. Bouali Educational and Research Publications.

Khaksar, D., & Gholami, H. (2018). Iran's judicial criminal policy regarding alternatives to imprisonment. Criminal Law and Criminology Research(11), 131-159.

Khodadadi, M., & Dadashnejad Delshad, D. (2022). Obstacles to implementing alternatives to imprisonment under the 2013 Islamic Penal Code. Legal Studies(28), 147-162.

Khodadi, A., Atouf, H. A., & Matin-Parsa, M. (2022). Analysis of judicial decisions related to alternatives to imprisonment, with emphasis on unpaid community service. Judicial Legal Perspectives(97), 77-106.

Khomeini, S. R. M. (2000). Kitab al-Bay'. Institute for Compilation and Publication of Imam Khomeini's Works.

Makarem Shirazi, N. (1991). Al-Qawa'id al-Fiqhiyya. Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib School.

Mirkamali, S. A., Hajizadeh, N., & Abdolmaleki, A. (2023). The impact of penal managerialism on national judicial criminal policy, with emphasis on alternatives to imprisonment: Challenges and opportunities. Criminal Law and Criminology Research(22), 191-221.

Mohaghegh Damad, S. M. (1985). Principles of Islamic Jurisprudence. Center for Islamic Sciences Publishing.

Najafi Abrandabadi, A. H. (2012). Lectures on Topics in Criminal Sciences. Mizan Legal Foundation.

Parchami, D., & Derakhshan, F. (2020). Community-Based Sanctions as Alternatives to Imprisonment and Crime Reduction. Judiciary, Press and Publications Center.

Ramah, M. A. a.-S. (2020). Social Work in the Care of Prisoners. Al-Yazouri Publishing and Distribution Group.

Roghani, F. (2022). Decarceration of Women: Examining the Consequences of Imprisonment and Identifying Alternatives. Hezar Rang.

Sudiren, O. (2017). Alternatives to Imprisonment in England and Wales, Germany, and Turkey: A Comparative Study. Mizan Publishing.

Tabasi, N. a.-D. (1995). Cases of Imprisonment in Texts and Fatwas. Qom Seminary, Islamic Propagation Office, Publications Center.

Tabasi, N. a.-D. (2004). Imprisonment and Exile in the Sources of Islamic Legislation. Bustan-e Ketab.

Downloads

Publication Timeline

Published
Submitted
Revised
Accepted

Issue

Section

مقالات

How to Cite

Ahmadi, R. ., & Yarahmadi, H. (1406). An Examination of Legal Challenges and Strategies for Enhancing Alternatives to Imprisonment in Iranian and Egyptian Law. Comparative Studies in Jurisprudence, Law, and Politics, 1-26. https://csjlp.org/index.php/csjlp/article/view/838