A Comparative Study and Analysis of the Structure of Warranty Against Defects and Price Reduction in Egyptian and Iranian Law
Keywords:
Warranty Against Defects, Arsh, Price Reduction, Option for Defect, Contractual Balance, Iranian Law, Egyptian Law, CompensationAbstract
Warranty against defects is one of the most significant institutions of contract law, designed to protect the buyer against a reduction in the value or utility of the subject matter and to preserve the economic balance of the contractual exchange. In Iranian law, this institution is primarily regulated through the option for defect and the right to claim arsh. Arsh enables the buyer to retain the defective subject matter without rescinding the contract while receiving compensation for the diminution in value caused by the defect. Nevertheless, the structural dependence of arsh on the option for defect and continuing disagreements concerning its legal nature, including whether it constitutes restitution of part of the price, compensation, or a mechanism for restoring commutative balance, have limited the clarity of its scope and effects. By contrast, Egyptian law regulates warranty against defects within a broader framework of the seller’s contractual obligations and remedies for defective performance, recognizing price reduction as a mechanism for preserving the contract and restoring its economic equilibrium. Using a descriptive-analytical method and a comparative approach, this study examines the foundations, requirements, and legal consequences of warranty against defects as well as the structure of arsh and price reduction in the two legal systems. The findings indicate that both mechanisms serve the common function of compensating for the diminished value of the contractual subject matter and reducing unnecessary reliance on rescission. However, price reduction in Egyptian law has a clearer relationship with the general system of contractual remedies and supplementary damages, whereas arsh in Iranian law remains largely confined to the traditional structure of the option for defect. The study concludes that reconstructing arsh as a mechanism for compensating measurable diminution in contractual value or utility, while distinguishing it from consequential damages and establishing clearer valuation criteria, could enhance the coherence of Iranian contract law and strengthen the preservation of contractual relationships.
References
Badawi, E. M. (2022). Good Faith Doctrine and Its Impact on Warranty Obligations in Commercial Contracts: Egyptian Judicial Practice. Global Law Publishing.
El-Awadi, N. (2020). A Comparative Analysis between the Concept of Arsh in Iran and the Warranty under the Egyptian Civil Code. International Review of Contract Law, 48(1), 201-225.
El-Dahshan, A. (2023). Harmonizing Contractual Fault with Civil Liability: Lessons from Egyptian Case Law. Alexandria Bar Association Press.
El-Hefny, A. (2021). The Civil Code of Egypt and Modern Contractual Guarantees. Cairo University Press.
Eskandari, F. (2022). A Comparative Study of the Legal Nature of Arsh in Imamiyya Jurisprudence and Iranian and French Law University of Tehran, Faculty of Law and Political Science].
Fahmy, A. (2024). The Egyptian Civil Code's Comprehensive Provisions on Warranty for Defects and Compensatory Justice. The Egyptian Law Review, 15(2), 45-68.
Farahmand, F., & Kashefi, R. (2025). Integrating the Law of Defective Goods Remedies with General Contractual Liability: A Critique of Arsh and Egyptian Models. Journal of Middle Eastern Legal Studies, 10(1), 10-35.
Ghasemi, H. (2021). The Role of Expert Assessment and Judicial Discretion in Determining Damages Arising from Defective Goods. Private Law Quarterly, 2(51), 301-322.
Haleeb, S. (2025). The Dynamic Approach of Egyptian Case Law in Defective Goods Remedies: A Shift towards Restorative Justice. Cairo University Law Journal, 50(3), 78-99.
Haliba, S. A. a.-F. (2025). Ahkam Istihqaq al-Mabi' lil-Ghayr fi al-Fiqh al-Islami wa al-Qanun al-Madani al-Misri wa al-Qatari. Al-Dirayah Publications.
Hassan, R. (2022). Abatement of Price vs. Rescission: Analyzing the Remedial Choice for Defective Performance in Civil Law Systems. Journal of Comparative Commercial Law, 15(3), 45-68.
Jafarimanesh, S. (2020). Economic Effects of Uncertainty in the Institution of Arsh on Commercial Transactions. Private Law Research Quarterly, 3(50), 45-68.
Katouzian, N. (2020a). The Civil Code in the Current Legal Order of Iran. Mizan.
Katouzian, N. (2020b). Civil Law: General Theory of Contracts. Ganj-e Danesh Publications.
Khaleel, R. (2020). Arsh in Iranian Law versus Price Reduction in Egyptian Law: A Study on the Sufficiency of Remedies. Journal of Comparative Legal Studies, 12(2), 150-175.
Mansour, K. (2021). The Evolution of Contractual Remedies in Egypt: From Traditional Warranty to Modern Contractual Balance. Cairo University Press.
Metwally, H. (2020). The Role of Legislative Codification in Achieving Predictability: A Post-Codification Analysis of the Egyptian Contracts Law. Law and Legislation Journal, 60(4), 120-145.
Mir Mohammad Sadeghi, H. (2020). The Effect of Contract Adjustment Instruments on Binding Force: A Comparative Study of Iranian and Egyptian Law. Mizan Publications.
Mirzaei, M. (2021). Challenges of Judicial Practice in Determining Judicial Compensation: A Case Study of Arsh in Capital Goods Disputes. Iran and World Comparative Law Journal, 2(15), 120-145.
Mousavi, S. A. (2021). A Jurisprudential-Legal Study of Arsh in Options Shahrekord University].
Omar, F. M. (2021). Buyer's Right to Information versus Seller's Duty of Disclosure: Comparative Perspectives on Defects. Journal of Commercial and Maritime Law, 28(1), 55-78.
Safwat, L. (2019). The Role of Istihqaq Bila Sabab Doctrine in Shaping Price Reduction Mechanisms under Egyptian Law. Private Law Studies, 45(3), 88-105.
Saleh, M. (2019). Comparative Study of Remedies for Defective Goods in Egyptian and French Law. Dar El-Nahda El-Arabia.
Seidan, H. (2024). Economic Underpinnings of Price Reduction: A Welfare Analysis Comparing Iran and Egypt. International Review of Economic Law, 10(2), 190-210.
Shams, A. (2020). Analysis of the Nature of Compensation for Deficiency in Commutative Contracts: A Case Study of the Institution of Arsh. Legal Research Journal, 20(45), 115-138.
Taha, A. (2023). Judicial Activity and Latent Defects: A Comparative View on Judicial Discretion in Iran and Egypt. Arab Law Quarterly, 37(1), 22-40.
Downloads
Publication Timeline
- Submitted
- Revised
- Accepted
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Hasan Mehrabi (Author); Davood Nasiran (Corresponding author); Ahmad Mohamadi (Author)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.